![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
cjlasky7There once was a note
Pure and easy
Playing so free
Like a breath / rippling by
"Pure and Easy"; Pete Townshend, Lifehouse
It's an essential aspect of the legend of The Who that their greatest album, Who's Next, was born out of the group's greatest failure.
As the follow up to Tommy, Pete Townshend conceived of an even grander project: Lifehouse, a science fiction epic that featured an early form of virtual reality, incorporation of synthesizers (at a level unheard of at that point in pop music), and even fourth-wall-breaking audience participation. The underlying philosophical concept was the Eternal Note: a vibration beyond physical forms that could unite human consciousness on a higher level--literally, the music of the spheres.
The rest of the band... didn't understand it. The preliminary concerts with audience participation? Utter disasters. So, discouraged and defeated, Townshend and his mates went into the studio to salvage the best songs from the project. And from those sessions we got:
Baba O' Riley. Behind Blue Eyes. Won't Get Fooled Again. Masterpieces.
I could ramble on about Lifehouse for a good long time (could I ever) but I just wanted to point out how it represents a pattern in almost all of The Who's music: in each of the band's greatest recordings, the protagonist is destroyed or defeated on the physical plane, but within that defeat is the hope of spiritual rebirth. Tommy loses his acolytes; Jimmy crashes his motorcycle on the rocks at Brighton (Quadrophenia); "meet the new boss, same as the old boss" (Won't Get Fooled Again); Pete Townshend hits bottom, wakes up in a Soho doorway after a drinking binge (Who Are You). Things may not work out, but the quest for spiritual fulfillment is what makes life worthwhile.
And maybe, maybe you need to be destroyed on some level to be open to growth. From perfect despair, there is hope. (Sound familiar, Buffy fans?)
I won't find what I'm after
Till the day I die
"The Seeker," Pete Townshend
They played "The Seeker" at MSG last night, that one and all the other songs of alienation and spiritual restlessness--songs that inspired The Clash, Pearl Jam, Green Day and everyone in between. Townshend didn't do any leaps or knee slides, but his guitar playing was as precise and ferocious as ever (he even treated us to a couple of vintage Townshend windmills).
[Pete was also chatty and funny: "I know you all work very hard at your jobs," he told the audience, "but this job? It's fucking easy!" Daltrey suppressed a laugh. "I don't know how we get paid for this!"]
The rest of the band? Ok, they're not Keith Moon and John Entwistle. But they played those parts with proficiency and passion. The big x factor that juiced up the ensemble was the second guitarist, none other than Pete Townshend's baby brother, Simon. Simon tore off the opening riff of "Pinball Wizard" and even took lead vocal on "Going Mobile"--a "Who's Next" gem never performed live before this tour (that's 54 years on the shelf).
As for Daltrey... he doesn't have the range he once did. His voice is rougher, and he can't sustain notes for long. ("We're fucking old!" said Pete, after Roger needed a re-take at the end of "Love Reign O'er Me.") But it didn't matter. He brought it when he had to and when he didn't, the audience was singing the song with him anyway.
Yes, me too. Every word.
We were just happy to see them, this last time. We wanted to show our appreciation for their music, for the stories they told that enriched our lives. That they were fallible, human, fighting the frailties of age, only brought them closer to us. They were rock gods, but they were also Pete and Roger, two mates who started out in 1961 hoping to make a living in music. In a sense, it was the communal experience that Townshend always wanted for Lifehouse.
[At the end of the show, Daltrey and Townshend stayed on stage to talk to the crowd, and Pete tried to explain the strange, wonderful chemistry he had with Roger. They're not friends. They don't socialize. But the combination, on some higher level, simply works.]
The final song from the full band was "The Song Is Over." It's mostly about the end of a love affair, but it's also about learning from that experience and moving on with your life in new directions. At the end of the song, the band repeated the refrain from "Pure and Easy" above, the Eternal Note showing us the way forward...
So is this really the end? (After all, The Who have retired before.) Whether or not they ever hit the Garden again, last night was special. It was more than enough.
Pure and easy
Playing so free
Like a breath / rippling by
"Pure and Easy"; Pete Townshend, Lifehouse
It's an essential aspect of the legend of The Who that their greatest album, Who's Next, was born out of the group's greatest failure.
As the follow up to Tommy, Pete Townshend conceived of an even grander project: Lifehouse, a science fiction epic that featured an early form of virtual reality, incorporation of synthesizers (at a level unheard of at that point in pop music), and even fourth-wall-breaking audience participation. The underlying philosophical concept was the Eternal Note: a vibration beyond physical forms that could unite human consciousness on a higher level--literally, the music of the spheres.
The rest of the band... didn't understand it. The preliminary concerts with audience participation? Utter disasters. So, discouraged and defeated, Townshend and his mates went into the studio to salvage the best songs from the project. And from those sessions we got:
Baba O' Riley. Behind Blue Eyes. Won't Get Fooled Again. Masterpieces.
I could ramble on about Lifehouse for a good long time (could I ever) but I just wanted to point out how it represents a pattern in almost all of The Who's music: in each of the band's greatest recordings, the protagonist is destroyed or defeated on the physical plane, but within that defeat is the hope of spiritual rebirth. Tommy loses his acolytes; Jimmy crashes his motorcycle on the rocks at Brighton (Quadrophenia); "meet the new boss, same as the old boss" (Won't Get Fooled Again); Pete Townshend hits bottom, wakes up in a Soho doorway after a drinking binge (Who Are You). Things may not work out, but the quest for spiritual fulfillment is what makes life worthwhile.
And maybe, maybe you need to be destroyed on some level to be open to growth. From perfect despair, there is hope. (Sound familiar, Buffy fans?)
I won't find what I'm after
Till the day I die
"The Seeker," Pete Townshend
They played "The Seeker" at MSG last night, that one and all the other songs of alienation and spiritual restlessness--songs that inspired The Clash, Pearl Jam, Green Day and everyone in between. Townshend didn't do any leaps or knee slides, but his guitar playing was as precise and ferocious as ever (he even treated us to a couple of vintage Townshend windmills).
[Pete was also chatty and funny: "I know you all work very hard at your jobs," he told the audience, "but this job? It's fucking easy!" Daltrey suppressed a laugh. "I don't know how we get paid for this!"]
The rest of the band? Ok, they're not Keith Moon and John Entwistle. But they played those parts with proficiency and passion. The big x factor that juiced up the ensemble was the second guitarist, none other than Pete Townshend's baby brother, Simon. Simon tore off the opening riff of "Pinball Wizard" and even took lead vocal on "Going Mobile"--a "Who's Next" gem never performed live before this tour (that's 54 years on the shelf).
As for Daltrey... he doesn't have the range he once did. His voice is rougher, and he can't sustain notes for long. ("We're fucking old!" said Pete, after Roger needed a re-take at the end of "Love Reign O'er Me.") But it didn't matter. He brought it when he had to and when he didn't, the audience was singing the song with him anyway.
Yes, me too. Every word.
We were just happy to see them, this last time. We wanted to show our appreciation for their music, for the stories they told that enriched our lives. That they were fallible, human, fighting the frailties of age, only brought them closer to us. They were rock gods, but they were also Pete and Roger, two mates who started out in 1961 hoping to make a living in music. In a sense, it was the communal experience that Townshend always wanted for Lifehouse.
[At the end of the show, Daltrey and Townshend stayed on stage to talk to the crowd, and Pete tried to explain the strange, wonderful chemistry he had with Roger. They're not friends. They don't socialize. But the combination, on some higher level, simply works.]
The final song from the full band was "The Song Is Over." It's mostly about the end of a love affair, but it's also about learning from that experience and moving on with your life in new directions. At the end of the song, the band repeated the refrain from "Pure and Easy" above, the Eternal Note showing us the way forward...
So is this really the end? (After all, The Who have retired before.) Whether or not they ever hit the Garden again, last night was special. It was more than enough.
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 01:44 am (UTC)Note - mooncustafer also wrote a review of the Who concert - he saw it in Toronto.
https://moon-custafer.dreamwidth.org/741819.html
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 02:57 am (UTC)Come back soon!
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 12:56 pm (UTC)At least two of the back-up musicians are named John, and Pete momentarily forgot the last name of one of them while introducing the band: “Um, Smith?” he said, as the guy prompted him: “I can’t always remember names. There are so many of us. More of ‘em keep turning up.”
Pete did quite a few windmills throughout the evening, and Roger also spun the microphone several times.
At the end they performed “The Song Is Over,” and then the rest of the band took the stage and Roger sang “Tea At the Theatre” with Pete playing acoustic guitar. I forget if it was before or after this that they joked with the audience about whether this was really for-real-this-time their last tour or if they were trolling us.
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 12:38 pm (UTC)(I’m not offended, btw—actually I’m sort of fascinated to learn I might come across as masc online)
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 05:15 pm (UTC)I keep trying to use they/their instead of gender specific pronouns but over 40 years of being taught the opposite...has not helped. ;-) I have to keep training my brain to go with they/them unless I know for certain; it's a glitch I can't quite kick entirely.
Actually it's your user name "moon_custafer" - my brain thinks it is male for some reason. When actually it's not gender specific.
Although been there myself - people online thought I was male too for a long time, I had to keep correcting them as well. Always bewildered me - but I guess I come across as male tone wise? Most people shorten my real name to it's non-gender more male version once they get to know me. So I may be she/their as well.
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 05:27 pm (UTC)I wonder if it’s the “er” at the end?
no subject
Date: 2025-09-04 11:00 pm (UTC)It's not the "moon" - it's the custafer part that is confusing my brain.
no subject
Date: 2025-09-08 01:28 am (UTC)Makes me want to download the Who now on my MP3 (aka my Iphone, which has better sound than one might think - I have Bose earphones - it's all about the earphones).
I like Daltry's voice - it's kind of rough but melodious. Pristine blue eyes, and a great voice.
And of course, we have Giles (ASH) singing The Who's Behind Blue Eyes in Buffy.
Thanks for the review.
no subject
Date: 2025-09-08 03:35 pm (UTC)It really was a special experience at MSG. I was tempted to call my post "An Intimate Evening with The Who"--which, on the face of it, is ridiculous. The Who is supposed to be this massive, steamrolling rock and roll juggernaut; but Pete and Roger have never felt so vulnerable, so plainly human. That connection gave the songs that much more power.
Best possible birthday present (from me to me). But I did see another great performance on my actual birthday! I'll describe it in my next post. (Hint: I'm not going to throw away my shot!)
no subject
Date: 2025-09-08 03:40 pm (UTC)